related tdf#160971 gtk3 a11y: Keep new combobox value
Selecting a new value in an editable combobox using
the gtk3 VCL plugin using the popup didn't work when
that popup was opened using the keyboard, sample
scenario:
1) Start Writer
2) Press F6 until the Formatting toolbar has focus
3) Press Tab until the "Font Name" combobox has focus
4) Press Alt+Down to open the combobox popup
5) Press Down key a few times to select another font, e.g.
"Carlito"
6) Press Enter to confirm
Rather than the newly selected font, the previously
set one would still be set in the combobox.
Selecting a new font using the popup would work however
when clicking the combobox's button using the mouse
instead of steps 1-4 above.
The problem was that restoring focus was resulting
in the newly selected value not getting saved.
Backtrace for how the value already got properly saved
for the case where the button was previously clicked
using the mouse:
1 weld::ComboBox::save_value weld.hxx 853 0x7f19a7af3f81
2 FontNameBox::save_value ctrlbox.hxx 369 0x7f19a7b01f3d
3 (anonymous namespace)::SvxFontNameBox_Base::statusChanged_Impl tbcontrl.cxx 3432 0x7f19a7ad95e0
4 (anonymous namespace)::SvxFontNameToolBoxControl::statusChanged tbcontrl.cxx 3439 0x7f19a7ad8312
5 SfxStatusDispatcher::sendStatusChanged(rtl::OUString const&, com::sun::star::frame::FeatureStateEvent const&)::$_0::operator()(com::sun::star::uno::Reference<com::sun::star::frame::XStatusListener> const&) const unoctitm.cxx 132 0x7f19a98ae241
6 comphelper::OInterfaceContainerHelper4<com::sun::star::frame::XStatusListener>::forEach<SfxStatusDispatcher::sendStatusChanged(rtl::OUString const&, com::sun::star::frame::FeatureStateEvent const&)::$_0>(std::unique_lock<std::mutex>&, SfxStatusDispatcher::sendStatusChanged(rtl::OUString const&, com::sun::star::frame::FeatureStateEvent const&)::$_0 const&) const interfacecontainer4.hxx 304 0x7f19a98a4411
7 SfxStatusDispatcher::sendStatusChanged unoctitm.cxx 129 0x7f19a98a42aa
8 SfxDispatchController_Impl::sendStatusChanged unoctitm.cxx 802 0x7f19a98a907c
9 SfxDispatchController_Impl::StateChanged unoctitm.cxx 885 0x7f19a98a987a
10 SfxStateCache::SetState_Impl statcach.cxx 424 0x7f19a98308cc
11 SfxStateCache::SetState statcach.cxx 328 0x7f19a98306f2
12 SfxBindings::UpdateControllers_Impl bindings.cxx 1211 0x7f19a97aeffd
13 SfxBindings::Update_Impl bindings.cxx 274 0x7f19a97ae5cf
14 SfxBindings::Update bindings.cxx 353 0x7f19a97af682
15 SfxDispatcher::Call_Impl dispatch.cxx 280 0x7f19a97c731c
16 SfxDispatcher::Execute_ dispatch.cxx 753 0x7f19a97cbc4b
17 SfxDispatcher::Execute dispatch.cxx 812 0x7f19a97cc02f
18 SfxDispatchController_Impl::dispatch unoctitm.cxx 671 0x7f19a98a6673
19 SfxOfficeDispatch::dispatch unoctitm.cxx 250 0x7f19a98a511a
20 SfxToolBoxControl::Dispatch tbxitem.cxx 253 0x7f19a9df168f
21 (anonymous namespace)::SvxFontNameBox_Base::Select tbcontrl.cxx 2007 0x7f19a7adb44a
22 (anonymous namespace)::SvxFontNameBox_Base::SelectHdl tbcontrl.cxx 1962 0x7f19a7adafb4
23 (anonymous namespace)::SvxFontNameBox_Base::LinkStubSelectHdl tbcontrl.cxx 1960 0x7f19a7adab9d
24 Link<weld::ComboBox&, void>::Call link.hxx 111 0x7f199a19ddd8
25 weld::ComboBox::signal_changed weld.hxx 731 0x7f199a19dd8c
26 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::fire_signal_changed gtkinst.cxx 21229 0x7f199a0e1880
27 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::handle_row_activated gtkinst.cxx 21891 0x7f199a0e17f9
28 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::signalRowActivated gtkinst.cxx 21876 0x7f199a0dd299
29 ?? 0x7f1999695931
30 ?? 0x7f19a87b4939
31 ?? 0x7f19a87ca33f
32 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
33 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
34 ?? 0x7f199993384b
35 ?? 0x7f1999697085
36 ?? 0x7f19a87b4939
37 ?? 0x7f19a87ca33f
38 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
39 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
40 ?? 0x7f19997b317e
41 g_cclosure_marshal_VOID__BOXEDv 0x7f19a87b7b76
42 ?? 0x7f19a87b4939
43 ?? 0x7f19a87ca33f
44 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
45 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
46 ?? 0x7f19997b0213
47 ?? 0x7f19997b1803
48 ?? 0x7f19997b4a42
49 gtk_event_controller_handle_event 0x7f1999779361
50 ?? 0x7f19999488bd
51 ?? 0x7f1999690db8
52 ?? 0x7f19a87b4939
53 ?? 0x7f19a87c9693
54 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
55 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
56 ?? 0x7f199994a314
57 ?? 0x7f19997fc84e
58 gtk_main_do_event 0x7f19997fe4be
59 ?? 0x7f199a7b1a79
60 ?? 0x7f199a7e5586
61 ?? 0x7f199ed1ce3f
62 ?? 0x7f199ed1eec7
63 g_main_context_iteration 0x7f199ed1f4e0
64 GtkSalData::Yield gtkdata.cxx 405 0x7f199a08827f
65 GtkInstance::DoYield gtkinst.cxx 427 0x7f199a08d6e3
66 ImplYield svapp.cxx 384 0x7f19a47bf65c
67 Application::Yield svapp.cxx 472 0x7f19a47bef6b
68 Application::Execute svapp.cxx 359 0x7f19a47bed02
69 desktop::Desktop::Main app.cxx 1652 0x7f19ad928434
70 ImplSVMain svmain.cxx 229 0x7f19a47e226e
71 SVMain svmain.cxx 261 0x7f19a47e4299
72 soffice_main sofficemain.cxx 93 0x7f19ad9aca7c
73 sal_main main.c 51 0x55cb2e25aa5d
74 main main.c 49 0x55cb2e25aa37
However, for the keyboard-only case, `GtkInstanceComboBox::m_bChangedByMenu`
got reset to false in `set_active_including_mru` with this backtrace:
1 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::set_active_including_mru gtkinst.cxx 21976 0x7f199a0e812b
2 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::set_active gtkinst.cxx 22406 0x7f199a0de9dc
3 FontNameBox::set_active_or_entry_text ctrlbox.cxx 897 0x7f19a64d904c
4 (anonymous namespace)::SvxFontNameBox_Base::set_active_or_entry_text tbcontrl.cxx 1823 0x7f19a7ad983d
5 (anonymous namespace)::SvxFontNameBox_Base::FocusOutHdl tbcontrl.cxx 1872 0x7f19a7adb9e2
6 (anonymous namespace)::SvxFontNameBox_Base::LinkStubFocusOutHdl tbcontrl.cxx 1868 0x7f19a7adac5d
7 Link<weld::Widget&, void>::Call link.hxx 111 0x7f199a13b618
8 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceWidget::signal_focus_out gtkinst.cxx 2630 0x7f199a0a1ef6
9 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::signal_entry_focus_out gtkinst.cxx 21427 0x7f199a0e83f6
10 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::signalEntryFocusOut gtkinst.cxx 21412 0x7f199a0dd525
11 ?? 0x7f1999690caa
12 g_closure_invoke 0x7f19a87b4730
13 ?? 0x7f19a87c887c
14 ?? 0x7f19a87c9ad1
15 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
16 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
17 ?? 0x7f199994a314
18 gtk_widget_send_focus_change 0x7f199995c0ea
19 ?? 0x7f199996153b
20 ?? 0x7f1999961822
21 g_closure_invoke 0x7f19a87b4730
22 ?? 0x7f19a87c8f08
23 ?? 0x7f19a87ca281
24 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
25 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
26 ?? 0x7f19a87b4939
27 ?? 0x7f19a87ca33f
28 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
29 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
30 gtk_widget_grab_focus 0x7f199994e7fa
31 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::menu_toggled gtkinst.cxx 21320 0x7f199a0ea4b8
32 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::signal_popup_toggled gtkinst.cxx 21356 0x7f199a0de2e9
33 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::signalPopupToggled gtkinst.cxx 21236 0x7f199a0dd375
34 g_closure_invoke 0x7f19a87b4730
35 ?? 0x7f19a87c887c
36 ?? 0x7f19a87ca281
37 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
38 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
39 ?? 0x7f19998f7ac5
40 ?? 0x7f19a87b4939
41 ?? 0x7f19a87ca33f
42 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
43 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
44 gtk_toggle_button_set_active 0x7f19998f7868
45 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::handle_row_activated gtkinst.cxx 21890 0x7f199a0e17f0
46 (anonymous namespace)::GtkInstanceComboBox::signalRowActivated gtkinst.cxx 21876 0x7f199a0dd299
47 ?? 0x7f1999695931
48 ?? 0x7f19a87b4939
49 ?? 0x7f19a87ca33f
50 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
51 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
52 ?? 0x7f1999935562
53 ?? 0x7f1999693eca
54 g_closure_invoke 0x7f19a87b4730
55 ?? 0x7f19a87c8f08
56 g_signal_emitv 0x7f19a87cfcf2
57 ?? 0x7f19996c773d
58 ?? 0x7f19996c7bf8
59 ?? 0x7f19996c7d80
60 gtk_bindings_activate_event 0x7f19996c922b
61 ?? 0x7f1999936b18
62 ?? 0x7f1999690db8
63 ?? 0x7f19a87b4894
64 ?? 0x7f19a87c9693
65 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
66 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
67 ?? 0x7f199994a314
68 gtk_window_propagate_key_event 0x7f199996cdeb
69 ?? 0x7f199997143b
70 ?? 0x7f1999690caa
71 g_closure_invoke 0x7f19a87b4730
72 ?? 0x7f19a87c8f08
73 ?? 0x7f19a87c9ad1
74 g_signal_emit_valist 0x7f19a87cff06
75 g_signal_emit 0x7f19a87cffc3
76 ?? 0x7f199994a314
77 ?? 0x7f19997fc8ff
78 gtk_main_do_event 0x7f19997fe4be
79 ?? 0x7f199a7b1a79
80 ?? 0x7f199a7e5586
81 ?? 0x7f199ed1ce3f
82 ?? 0x7f199ed1eec7
83 g_main_context_iteration 0x7f199ed1f4e0
84 GtkSalData::Yield gtkdata.cxx 405 0x7f199a08827f
85 GtkInstance::DoYield gtkinst.cxx 427 0x7f199a08d6e3
86 ImplYield svapp.cxx 384 0x7f19a47bf65c
87 Application::Yield svapp.cxx 472 0x7f19a47bef6b
88 Application::Execute svapp.cxx 359 0x7f19a47bed02
89 desktop::Desktop::Main app.cxx 1652 0x7f19ad928434
90 ImplSVMain svmain.cxx 229 0x7f19a47e226e
91 SVMain svmain.cxx 261 0x7f19a47e4299
92 soffice_main sofficemain.cxx 93 0x7f19ad9aca7c
93 sal_main main.c 51 0x55cb2e25aa5d
94 main main.c 49 0x55cb2e25aa37
As a consequence, `GtkInstanceComboBox::changed_by_direct_pick` would
then return false when called in `SvxFontNameBox_Base::SelectHdl` (s.
frame 21 in the first backtrace above), so the new value wouldn't get
saved, but the previous one would get used instead since
commit 131c1c7da8c567636ca55751e49d24cb6d6c9b9e
Date: Sun Nov 21 19:53:47 2021 +0000
Related: tdf#145786 cooperate between our own grabs
, which introduced grabbing the focus for the combobox
in `GtkInstanceComboBox::menu_toggled` (s. frame 31 in above
backtrace).
Fix this by calling `fire_signal_changed` before
`gtk_toggle_button_set_active` in
`GtkInstanceComboBox::handle_row_activated`
(s. frame 26 in the first and frame 44 in the second
backtrace above), so `m_bChangedByMenu` only gets reset
to false at the end of `fire_signal_changed`, not before it gets
called.
With that in place, the new value now gets set and the
combobox shows the newly selected value as expected.
Change-Id: Ib1919a99b46c33981593d9c5ec9a0d21443890b3
Reviewed-on: https://gerrit.libreoffice.org/c/core/+/168146
Tested-by: Jenkins
Reviewed-by: Michael Weghorn <m.weghorn@posteo.de>
diff --git a/vcl/unx/gtk3/gtkinst.cxx b/vcl/unx/gtk3/gtkinst.cxx
index 6e4f95d..94963428 100644
--- a/vcl/unx/gtk3/gtkinst.cxx
+++ b/vcl/unx/gtk3/gtkinst.cxx
@@ -20101,8 +20101,8 @@ private:
else
tree_view_set_cursor(nActive);
#endif
enable_notify_events();
// gtk_toggle_button_set_active(GTK_TOGGLE_BUTTON(m_pToggleButton), false);
enable_notify_events();
fire_signal_changed();
update_mru();
}
@@ -21887,8 +21887,8 @@ private:
else
tree_view_set_cursor(nActive);
enable_notify_events();
gtk_toggle_button_set_active(GTK_TOGGLE_BUTTON(m_pToggleButton), false);
fire_signal_changed();
gtk_toggle_button_set_active(GTK_TOGGLE_BUTTON(m_pToggleButton), false);
update_mru();
}
